i§Tl?JAEI?I‘J'_-i'E§‘5‘§fi‘fi‘Z§1§I5l‘J»lL~Hf‘J E3l?%5%”Tf."E‘J$é?-fl

uz~@u%—-£13m: i§T‘?%%¥F755IE‘IFfi1l3EZEf§"iE1B<JIJ‘J9§EE4J$>BE i9T¥§~%EI‘J:tflfl\EEEE‘JJLE

uZ~?)fi4<‘-3~~’£JJfiHfi

‘ififi 1+/AETUWEE 5 EH

5%?’ E Ei3fi?§7€7‘:'lJE4J1“.i”afl§3Ifi

l3;€%T E Efiifififvflflfififité

‘IQE E EHE‘J§§E!E‘J‘éa‘$T<’d!.fi7$%7§Ti#%:‘"X

fi+E$

&&#m$@m%mmzx Emamwxmafiwx fi¢a$%E£%%%& z+am%emxm&%mAam mfimaaém

z+am$%§%mmv#

fiamw mmmgm fl$fi£fii%&¥mmmfi

i+am%%§m£@

a¢am

%$fi~fi%m

fiT£¢E$

M%fi—flfi$

ffifiufifiifiéiéwfi

fi%¥mfiufi$

fir En‘=3=ab~( i%%; 19?. 2&5)

its ((-ti-»??~§;'#'))1962 £r- 7.8 fl %( 109 / 110 #1)

[E1 2&1 4=2H4%a’J ir¥7lUl=E

iZE?€$EE7l<1‘E. $E$E?J"Lfi]fiJ . i>i<.71<EftE%§ , E4fi$I%iE5}J§E?EB‘J Eflflfi.

180 -

EMfi%@fi%@*fi; {$3E$fim%fi$fi$mm$. E%%fl%%flu Wfifimmfi, agfiwxmmgmmxwmm. Ew§%Hfi%m%fifi§fi, %%finMIAfi%i¢m\ fiiiéfiwwfi, Eflfi%mmfl%flE: N%%$$Lmfi%%%M, flxfififimfito zmwxafiamfi, %2$E‘?ti1B<Jéfi$“\%‘1I“J , m%mxa%axfi.

%+7=T5 Jéafi E E Efiiéfio IAEfl%MW%%E, %Kfifl:T%%%$¢: flifififigwfifia, w:aa§%mmfim, fimiifififlflmmwo z¢m,

%fi%fifl*fi;

§.l2m;a5u=e , sa4m?—¢v§ , fi1$%%fi%Exfi; m%&E:Awm%@. fi%EflB$Efi%%%E, Eflfififimmxifio 1%o$sH $%%%&2,ma«m£%—a$Aaa%£a% %%%M%fl#%4%2#3H$fi$1mL

1/\I%\é/3. LL/\¢?EA%%¢?§£fi*?

?:—’53«‘ffii’# E1 «How Marxism Works))( 2000 3- 6 F] ' 2?: 6 H5... Z37Jh‘)§.fi" 1979 51‘-),'T’F%‘ Chris Harman. iii? ~$%ia:xAn+w%um&%£fl¢@%°

Ikmfl (The woking class)

3E,EiE’§ <<33'E)"t§i’E—§>> VJ~iX1$i3‘JE‘;'Ex"3Wfz‘: ‘EU 5 'FT?T§§7itE‘J—’I9]?i/£l3‘J}335E%I3%[5fT§Ei3¥-%B‘JJ35§1o"

5‘??? l3)/I\?,3’L§'§$'JWEii.3.l5fI‘?l"L—*E}'7'E.°?.f’=W"n§ , ii E/|\9E%lE']Eo 7~JlHf., E1«‘JW$FI‘J§/I‘?i%-‘E. . l5jI‘§Z’LZ |'|§]'%‘%7;‘i$fiEjCI5"J3}'% .3-JFflZ_§":%'l5’I3IA|7‘]r5i——fi 3’-i3JE‘J1l5Z$iE§)‘L, "FTfi‘iE.E7\"¥}f|l§‘JZ?E3:flSL, 17 E 18 111‘ ZE'.3‘JjC%Jrz'.7fi|7‘]u55'Z—'3$fiJ‘o

EFJf7§5i1£—'E‘jE%fl1fi3l*%“P , }i39iH‘J39?/@515 E1“i’%' %§’EiEi3"J¥I353‘o 13% , 1II155?EE»%§§7F[‘3‘E|5"J. £11 $5 . 'fl§.1I’]F}?7§5¥7'II H935? . /':l%1«‘/I‘/I"/"§lJKEi‘J‘f‘§ 7F1%‘?€z‘fiI§ETI'7:39I‘—*‘/I\o EH31 , f57J1l[I3§EE4JC"F["§l, E fi§7J’U¥3£$'J 9"J1‘€E%@)‘4‘?{E4fi_3;1l“.l»'E».5\% U‘/l‘§% 4J€%€7':7'5’l‘-‘/l‘o F33#Ffl43.,?§Ei“£l$1jC$fiJ“PtH7'3§§E‘J % “3E.§’FE‘71”( bras nus )—"‘|”_:‘;§J”<-%’§1'$I3‘Jl5J/I\?5"LJL3_% 1'5‘ H7JJC[§lI*Ufi}5§%‘?fi‘E‘J . Z:%{1Ml‘] , Wfi;%’1'?E'/f:I 5311 :|:fll/.330‘

l5J’l\?;5iZ}5JTl3J5'€$XH’@.1l7f{i§’§3l* 39$fiJ‘3‘J ?§:“?F'J7f1,fil7W/I\$§J§El o

§9fi,1‘i/£917T§i39'-‘}§*i7J<¥i$7FE3J_—’!TEEo Rlfljlji §§5IAE2§’?fifi‘i{7‘§§'3fE?? , }5)fl«)HXfi—*/1931353‘ )\7€HTl'E7J$fll5FJHEi7,viE4i‘.7R5Ffl$3V$’§l§?’§fiX4Eo fifil W533: , fiEl%?i%‘§7iE . I‘)/l\§&E4Jfi'Ifl_.l!.9?§LlZ‘§ o

E??? , HIEiE|35I‘$&l3‘J$?§?§7§§§741P.TI‘]’¢é‘E¥i"z‘?%

. 143%‘/Eéo 7t12¥S.l:41i3.1l‘]‘¥£7E §C4t,fiMI‘]Xa‘ E E5F}f5L|‘iH3lZ

Zfil:E34J$%%'E4‘VA\1?*rI3‘4J,'3lfi XE//"WE, #3, .Eki:‘I4J§I€ fit . 4tMI‘]fi3E E19 £i._?fi1‘[‘M1i1.1I‘1éa‘%'J§§?&Z1ktfiX¢ B4J’H2lio ’v“l'§n’I‘5£‘€E,‘:l9éIE.~4’d1.FJT#Ffi'E!‘J—/J\i3&:l:ii.¥1o fiiifiififl

fi¢¥Ifl%R&%mEEW¢$EflfifiW5E %$Tfl%mE%%flWR%fi%o ma%mw+xmwa@mma§mfi@m: m:m,m%—am:m$m,mmm%%Awmm flfiiflfifi%%@omEEEfiWE%flEfl% “~+§%am2%§ummmum%%%%r§m amaaamfigjmammsxfiimmaam flfio Eflfifi$$XZTmfiM§%1Afi%¥% fi%fi%fiTEmfioEfi:m&fiI$E%A%E $%%%o%z§M§&wfi$¥m%§?fi¢$X &%aa§@u&%§&%fim%%%mx§%u %moagm§mue$mmm&mwmfi%m% %fifl%fi£fi%%%uEfi£Eo E%Lfi¢£XfiET%i%fiIAEWZfi& fi%$E&%°mmmfi¢$X%§%%%fi§fia §%IAJWifi$$Xfififl$tfiAfiAifi mamtfl:¢%m,mmEE¢ww%w%§¢a %mw—+m&&%mfixw§o IED?Umfi$IXfiIAE$F¢fifi€¢, filkfiaaflflflléwflfifiwfififiufi §5m%mm¥§mam§om$mmm%¢E— flfififiifimfiéiflmfiaiflfiflflfiwflfi. xnuaafiuémmmmmamwgfigfizo i@&fi¢$XfiW¥mfiE%%E%fi5%fi :Airaf:m" a4:w21:( @151 mama >M:sJz% was,¢m1r1ma%;1m:A—-1aé@:@:é>z&a<a mac filfi, 3EiEiEiRE<J7;iE—%EE§, /4%, aw: §%,afi;r%wam—@:A@usmmmEw fifiEIFZ%Efi%fioMm%%uE%fi@% a%m%¢w~¢m&ma@%——a~gm$$u Ewfifimfifififlmfifio %EE%$$§%fiIA%fi$fl%%flfifi mmfi&%mw§,ma%@maag%@%,fi$ #EflEEE%fi§dEfiEfiE%Wflfi%&fi& éaW$%flflfl%—+E%fi—M%fi%E:éo mmsm-sigma: “fi%%—wfi%#£9&A%.%9&A%fl

-181-